Rabbi Saadia Gaon explains that the sections Nitzavim and Vaielech are actually two parts of the same parashah (section). Some years they are read together, and some years separately. Given this, how can they have opposing content? The conceptual content of everything is expressed by its Hebrew name. This is true for all aspects of life, and even more so for matters of Torah. The name of one of this week's parashot is Nitzavim, which translates as "standing firm." This name denotes the concept of stability, the opposite of change. The name of the second parashah is Vaielech, which translates as "and it was." This name implies movement, progress, and change.

According to Rav Saadiah Gaon, how can it be that Nitzavim and Vaielech, which denote opposite contents (stability and change), are parts of the same section of the Torah?

Our sages teach us that the world is sustained on three pillars: the study of Torah, Tefillah (prayer), and the observance of Mitzvot (precepts).

In each of these three pillars, which make up the service of every Jew to God, there are these two opposing lines: Nitzavím, firmness, and Vaielej, movement.

Torah
The Torah is generally divided into two parts: the Written Torah and the Oral Torah. While both were given by God through Moses at Mount Sinai, each was given in a different form:

The written Torah is limited and fixed in the number of letters and words it contains; it cannot undergo any changes.

In contrast, the Oral Torah, which is the explanation of the Written Torah, is limitless. From a single word, or even a single letter of the Written Torah, extensive commentaries can arise in the Oral Torah, giving it an aspect of dynamism and constant evolution.

This does not mean that the commentaries of the Oral Torah on the Written Torah are "inventions" of the rabbis of each era. Our sages say that every new thing that any student might ever say was already given to Moses at Mount Sinai. This means that all The Oral Torah has already been delivered, but the responsibility to reveal those teachings that are still hidden falls on each of us.

Even within the realm of the Oral Torah, we find these two lines of thought. When a scholar reveals a new teaching in the Torah, for it to be considered valid (and therefore part of the Oral Torah), it must be based on the foundations received at Mount Sinai. These foundations of interpretation are fixed and immutable.

Here we see two opposing lines: on one hand, the Torah is static, whether it is the written Torah or the foundations of interpretation and deduction of the oral Torah, and on the other hand, it is dynamic, because new explanations and perspectives on the same issues are constantly being revealed.

Tefillah
Prayer is a commandment that applies equally to everyone. Moreover, it is daily, repetitive, and static. However, our sages call prayer "service with the heart." This concept implies the use of emotions in serving God. During prayer, it is expected that, through meditating on God's greatness, a Jew will develop love and awe of the Almighty in his heart. Since everyone's knowledge and intellectual capacity are different, the emotions developed by each person are also different.

Here again we see two opposing lines, in this case, in the service of prayer: on the one hand, it is static, the same for everyone, and cyclical. On the other hand, each person perceives God and connects to Him differently through prayer; there is a constant dynamism and change marked by the knowledge and capacity of each individual.

Mitzvot
The number of commandments in the Torah is fixed. God gave the Jewish people 613 commandments, none of which can be subtracted or added to.

Halakha, Jewish law, precisely defines and determines each of the precepts: how it should be fulfilled, when it applies, who must fulfill it, and so on.

However, there is also the idea of embellishing a precept, of observing it more strictly, of going beyond what the law requires, with the aim of not only fulfilling the Divine Will, but also trying to do so in the best way possible.

Finally, we see that in the observance of the Mitzvot, we also find these two opposing lines: on the one hand, there is a static aspect to the precepts, their definition is clear and fixed, and on the other hand, each person can improve their observance and embellish the precepts, giving them a dynamic and changing character, according to their own will.

The reason these two lines exist is that each expresses one of the two fundamental components in the relationship between God and the Jewish people: the aspect of firmness (Nitzavim) expresses the giver of the Torah and the Mitzvot, God, while the dynamic aspect (Veielech) expresses the receiver, the Jew.

That is why, explains Rav Saadiá Gaón, the two sections are part of the same thing, to teach us that the service to God, in general, requires, on the part of the Jew, two movements, one dynamic (Vaiélej) and one static (Nitzavim).

The lesson lies in understanding that every effort towards dynamism, updating and progress, has to To be successful is to be based on the static and firm foundations of the Torah and the Mitzvot.

Extracted from Likutei Sijot, vol 29, p. 173

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

10 − eight =

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.